Chip:
I'm still not sure exactly what you have done, but it sounds like you are off the beaten path.
You need to create a cue file and then burn from that cue file. I have no idea if you have done this. Cue files will have a cue extension, so you would have something like Gordon Lightfoot.cue, but you could call it anything.
Here is the exact sequence of steps. If you can't get anywhere with this explanation, send me private mail.
1: Convert the files you intend to burn from mp3 to WAV if you need to. Not all CD players will play mp3s.
2: Open Imgburn. Switch to Write mode from Mode menu.
3: Choose create CD cue file from Tools menu. A window will pop open.
4: Choose browse for a file from the folder icon at the upper right of that window. An explorer type window will open showing your drives and folders.
5: Navigate to the folder with your Lightfoot songs. Select each file you want to burn with the mouse. Choose open from the bottom of the window when all are selected. If the files are scattered across several folders, choose the first folder, select the songs in the first folder, choose open, and then navigate to the next folder and repeat the process.
6: When all files have been selected and opened, you should be back at the "create CD cue file" window. The songs will be in ALPHA order, not your chosen order.
7: Notice the 4 little arrows along the right side of that window. If you select a song, you can use those arrows to move it up or down in the list. Move each song around until they are displayed in your chosen order.
8: Depending on how you like to work, you might want to check the 'Add To Write Queue When Done' box here. By doing so, you won't then have to load it manually when you are ready to burn.
9: When songs are in the correct order, choose OK at the bottom of the Create CD cue file window.
10: A save as window will pop open. Give it a name and save it wherever you want. This is the Cue file. Note that it has a CUE extension. A cue file is just a list of your songs in proper order,showing where they are on your disc. When you burn, Imgburn will refer to the list to find the songs and order them properly.
11: You should now be back at the main Imgburn window. Choose your write speed at the lower right. You can choose the "test mode" checkbox in the lower left if you want to make a dry run to see if it will burn.
12: Poke the big "write" button to the left of the green arrow at the lower left to begin the burn. I normally choose verify also.
That's it. Burning will start assuming you followed step 8 above.
I deliberately left out setting whatever blank gap you may want between songs. And I deliberately omitted the "CD text" stuff, which I personally never use. You can fiddle with that stuff yourself if you use it.
When the disc is done, play it back to confirm things are in proper order.
Note: I did no manual renumbering or anything like that.
You don't have to save the CUE file unless you think you might eventually reburn another identical Lightfoot disc. Normally, I just confirm that the disc plays well and then delete the CUE file. You can always make a new one.
There is normally no need to "save a project" or anything like that. Just save the cue file, burn, and then delete the cue file when satisfied.
Below are 2 images of a sample CD burn of Dean Martin songs. The first shows the songs in Alpha order, just after I selected them and loaded them into Imgburn. The second image shows the reordered songs, just before I saved the Cue file. They will burn in the order shown in the second image.
Send private mail if you are still fouled up.