| Author |
Topic: Why does classic country rarely use minor chords ? |
Matt Kidney
From:
Galway, Eire
|
Posted 20 Jul 2023 12:14 am |
|
but frequently uses secondary dominants
I'm not much of a classic country type but it's fairly hard to avoid learning pedal steel. I'm just wondering if there is a reason for it.
_________________
www.myspace.com/pboy |
|
|
|
Pete Bailey
From:
Seattle, WA
|
Posted 20 Jul 2023 5:39 am
|
|
| A quick browse through the Hank Williams repertoire (for example) will show that your premise is simply not true. |
|
|
|
Erv Niehaus
From:
Litchfield, MN, USA
|
Posted 20 Jul 2023 6:41 am
|
|
I use a lot of minor chords when I write tab for country songs.
Erv |
|
|
|
Dave Mudgett
From:
Central Pennsylvania and Gallatin, Tennessee
|
Posted 20 Jul 2023 7:14 am
|
|
Well, there's "Three Chords and the Truth". But yeah, there's Hank, Patsy Cline, Marty Robbins, and so many more where it's not just 1-4-5. If you consider bluegrass 'classic country', I think that opens things up even more, since a significant amount of mountain music has a minor-modal sound.
I think there are actually multiple issues here - various uses of minor chords in a song and songs with an actual minor key center. I think minor key songs in most popular genres are the minority. I see country music as fairly typical in that regard, but there are plenty of well known examples. More here - https://www.tdpri.com/threads/country-songs-in-a-minor-key.276557/ - and there are lots more examples beyond these.
As far as use of minor chords in a major key center song, there are various issues there. In classic jazz and much popular music, minor or min7 chords and extensions are frequently used as passing chords. A lot of classic pop music re-harmonized simpler songs (including plenty of country songs) in a more jazz/pop-inflected way - consider various versions of I'm So Lonesome I Could Cry by BJ Thomas and others. And lots more. More sophisticated classic country (think Patsy Cline, Ray Price, Willie Nelson, Jim Reeves, and many others) used passing chords like this quite a bit. Crazy may be the classic example, but there are lots more.
And yet other classic country just used minor chords in a major key center song as an integral part of the harmonization of the melody. El Paso and Big Iron by Marty Robbins are just a couple of many, many examples.
So I also disagree with your premise. I often find myself using minor chords in many positions when playing steel on country material. Or guitar. |
|
|
|
K Maul
From:
Hadley, NY/Hobe Sound, FL
|
Posted 20 Jul 2023 7:45 am Re: Why does classic country rarely use minor chords ?
|
|
| Matt Kidney wrote: |
but frequently uses secondary dominants
I'm not much of a classic country type but it's fairly hard to avoid learning pedal steel. I'm just wondering if there is a reason for it. |
Untrue, but I find this post to be only a minor irritation for me.
_________________
Kevin Maul: Airline, Beard, Clinesmith, Decophonic, Evans, Excel, Fender, Fluger, Gibson, Hilton, Ibanez, Justice, K+K, Live Strings, MOYO, National, Oahu, Peterson, Quilter, Rickenbacher, Sho~Bud, Supro, TC, Ultimate, VHT, Williams, X-otic, Yamaha, ZKing. |
|
|
|
Donny Hinson
From:
Glen Burnie, Md. U.S.A.
|
Posted 20 Jul 2023 10:21 am My simple-minded take on the subject…
|
|
For many forms of music, major chords connote happy and upbeat feelings, and minor chords connote the sad and foreboding feelings.
But country music seems mostly dominated by major chords, so the sad and foreboding feelings are often generated by the lyrics.
Minor seventh chords are said to be the saddest chord form, while the G-major chord is said to be the “happiest” chord. That’s why its used most often in casinos for the audio on slot machines…feel good music! |
|
|
|
Fred Treece
From:
California, USA
|
Posted 21 Jul 2023 2:42 pm
|
|
Because great classic country writers didn’t need minor chords.
Seriously, there’s more than just the lyric that can make otherwise happy sounding chord progressions sound pathetically sad. “Your Cheating Heart”, “Oh Lonesome Me”, “He Stopped Loving Her Today”, “When I Call Your Name” —- I mean jeez…if those songs had minor chords in them they would have caused mass suicide. |
|
|
|
Donny Hinson
From:
Glen Burnie, Md. U.S.A.
|
Posted 22 Jul 2023 4:34 am
|
|
| Fred Treece wrote: |
| ...Seriously, there’s more than just the lyric that can make otherwise happy sounding chord progressions sound pathetically sad. “Your Cheating Heart”, “Oh Lonesome Me”, “He Stopped Loving Her Today”, “When I Call Your Name” —- I mean jeez…if those songs had minor chords in them they would have caused mass suicide. |
 Good one, Fred!
I tried to think of a happy, cheerful song that was written in a minor key, but I couldn't come up with single one?  There have been, of course, some very famous country songs written in minors. Here's a dozen or so that I've played throughout the years, in pretty much (chronological) order:
Blue Prairie
Kaw Liga
Ghost Riders In The Sky
Sixteen Tons
Blackjack County Chain
Wichita Lineman
The Devil Went Down To Georgia
Jolene
Somebody's Knockin'
I Loved Them Every One
A Country Boy Can Survive
Thinkin' Thing
Thunder Rolls |
|
|
|
Matt Kidney
From:
Galway, Eire
|
Posted 25 Jul 2023 4:58 am
|
|
Hmm
I was specifically thinking of songs in major keys, and maybe it's just the songs the guys I meet up with introduce me to where there seems to be 2 major and 3 major chords being used, Borrowed Angel, Tennessee Waltz come to mind.
_________________
www.myspace.com/pboy |
|
|
|
Fred Treece
From:
California, USA
|
Posted 25 Jul 2023 6:35 am
|
|
| Classic Country from the 40’s-60’s grew out of American Folk, Gospel, Swing, and Blues. For every minor-mode song in any of those traditions, there are 10 that would not even have a minor chord in them, and the melodies would be pretty straight diatonic or pentatonic. If you are asking why that is, a music historian might have a better answer, but my peanut gallery perspective on it is that a country song is about telling a story with a certain degree of emotional wallop that the average unsophisticated listener can appreciate, sing along with, and dance to. It is not necessarily meant to be a trip through the land of rhythmic and harmonic complexity, just like the traditions that comprise the country music wellspring were not. It is a testament to the power of Country music and the brilliance of its writers that so much musical and lyrical expression can be wrung out of basic diatonic structures and rhyme schemes. |
|
|
|
Ken Pippus
From:
Langford, BC, Canada
|
Posted 25 Jul 2023 7:56 am
|
|
| Playing Tennessee Waltz without any minor chords isn’t a beautiful thing. |
|
|
|
Donny Hinson
From:
Glen Burnie, Md. U.S.A.
|
Posted 26 Jul 2023 6:40 am
|
|
| Ken Pippus wrote: |
| Playing Tennessee Waltz without any minor chords isn’t a beautiful thing. |
The song as written has no minor chords, and not even the most popular version (by Patti Page) had any minor chords in the arrangement. But I, too, will throw in a 2m and 4m, and even a diminished or two sometimes when I’m playing it.
Each to his own.  |
|
|
|
Erv Niehaus
From:
Litchfield, MN, USA
|
Posted 26 Jul 2023 6:46 am
|
|
I try to stay away from those demented chords though. 
Erv |
|
|
|
Fred Treece
From:
California, USA
|
Posted 26 Jul 2023 7:53 am
|
|
| Ken Pippus wrote: |
| Playing Tennessee Waltz without any minor chords isn’t a beautiful thing. |
Beg to differ.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=L_PRWKS1his
Plus, I like the way she pronounces the word “lost”. |
|
|
|
Garry Vanderlinde
From:
CA
|
Posted 26 Jul 2023 12:18 pm
|
|
If you notice when going to clubs and bars where country music is played there's a sign out front that says "NO MINORS ALLOWED!"
 |
|
|
|
Fred Treece
From:
California, USA
|
Posted 26 Jul 2023 12:51 pm
|
|
| Garry Vanderlinde wrote: |
If you notice when going to clubs and bars where country music is played there's a sign out front that says "NO MINORS ALLOWED!"
|
🤣 |
|
|
|
Don R Brown
From:
Rochester, New York, USA
|
Posted 26 Jul 2023 7:29 pm
|
|
| Garry Vanderlinde wrote: |
If you notice when going to clubs and bars where country music is played there's a sign out front that says "NO MINORS ALLOWED!"
|
You can THINK them, but you can't SING them. They misspelled "aloud".
_________________
Many play better than I do. Nobody has more fun. |
|
|
|
Jack Stoner
From:
Kansas City, MO
|
Posted 27 Jul 2023 8:10 am
|
|
When I took guitar lessons, in the late 40's (yes I know I'm old) I was only taught major and 7th chords. No minors, diminished, etc - these were "orchestra chords" and not needed for country.
Obviously, a lot has changed over the years, but that was how it was 'back them".
_________________
GFI Ultra Keyless S-10 with pad (Black of course) TB202 amp, Hilton VP, Steelers Choice sidekick seat
Cakewalk by Bandlab and Studio One V4.6 pro DAWs, MOTU Ultralite MK5 recording interface unit (for sale) |
|
|
|
Bob Hoffnar
From:
Austin, Tx
|
Posted 28 Jul 2023 4:52 am Re: Why does classic country rarely use minor chords ?
|
|
| Matt Kidney wrote: |
but frequently uses secondary dominants
I'm not much of a classic country type but it's fairly hard to avoid learning pedal steel. I'm just wondering if there is a reason for it. |
I think it is because the one, four and five major triads contain every note in the major scale making so it can harmonize most basic melodies. The dominant chords act as the most basic form passing tones. The b7 added to the one chord also can act as a harmonization to a more blues influenced melody along with being a transition to the four chord.
If you are looking for a more historical reason if someone is singing a melody they can find a way to accompany themselves with those three basic chords without much effort. Also country music seems to come from European diatonic based melodies giving us the basic one, four and five chords. Then it was heavily influenced by blues which makes the dominant seventh an big part of the harmonic structure.
_________________
Bob |
|
|
|
Joachim Kettner
From:
Germany
|
Posted 28 Jul 2023 6:53 am
|
|
Look what Leon Russel had done (I don't know if he came up first with the idea) with this Hank Williams song. You'll find augmented and minor chords and a key change:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BSvlpM2twMk
_________________
Fender Kingman, Sierra Crown D-10, Evans Amplifier, Soup Cube. |
|
|
|
Dan Behringer
From:
Jerseyville, Illinois
|
Posted 29 Jul 2023 1:10 pm
|
|
| Reading this thread, I can’t help but think of the phrase “There is beauty in simplicity.” Music is about creating something that sounds beautiful and you really don’t need big fancy chords to accomplish that. |
|
|
|
Erv Niehaus
From:
Litchfield, MN, USA
|
Posted 31 Jul 2023 6:48 am
|
|
To make music beautiful sometimes you need those "big fancy chords".
They add richness to the song and help fill it out.
Erv
Last edited by Erv Niehaus on 31 Jul 2023 7:14 am; edited 1 time in total |
|
|
|
Chris Templeton
From:
The Green Mountain State
|
Posted 31 Jul 2023 7:08 am
|
|
Great comments about the mood of major and minor chords.
One time I said to Buddy that a Maj7 chord was happy and uplifting and he replied that there is a lot of tension with one.
_________________
Excel 3/4 Pedal With An 8 String Hawaiian Neck, Tapper (10 string with a raised fretboard to fret with fingers), Single neck Fessenden 3/5
"The Tapper" : https://christophertempleton.bandcamp.com/album/the-tapper
Soundcloud Playlist: https://soundcloud.com/bluespruce8: |
|
|
|
scott murray
From:
Asheville, NC
|
Posted 31 Jul 2023 6:56 pm
|
|
| Chris Templeton wrote: |
Great comments about the mood of major and minor chords.
One time I said to Buddy that a Maj7 chord was happy and uplifting and he replied that there is a lot of tension with one. |
in his Basic C6 course Buddy states:
"The C6 and CMaj7 chords are somewhat harsh sounding compared to the mellow texture of the dominant 7 (C7)."
can't say I agree with that!
_________________
1965 Emmons S-10, 3x5 • Emmons LLIII D-10, 10x12 • JCH D-10, 10x12 • Beard MA-8 • Oahu Tonemaster |
|
|
|
Chris Templeton
From:
The Green Mountain State
|
|
|
|
